LOUISIANA BASKETBALL HALL OF FAME
McCalebb was an honorable mention AP All-American in 2007 and CollegeInsider Mid-Major All-American in 2008, as well as a three-time first team NABC All-District and two-time USBWA All-District selection. He was also a two-time Louisiana Player of the Year, and a three-time first team and once third team All-Louisiana selection. Additionally, he was a three-time first team All-Sun Belt Conference and two-time SBC All-Tournament selection, as well as the SBC Player of the Year in 2007, Defensive Player of the Year in 2008, and Freshman of the Year and Tournament Most Outstanding Player in 2004. He finished his career as the leading scorer in New Orleans and SBC history (and ranked 21st in NCAA DI history), with 2,679 points for a 20.9 average, 601 rebounds for a 4.7 average and a school record 250 steals for a 1.95 average. He averaged 23.2 points (9th in nation and 1st in SBC), 4.5 rebounds and 2.38 steals (1st in SBC) and had a 50.6% field goal percentage in 2008. He averaged 25.0 points (6th in nation and 1st in SBC), 6.8 rebounds and 2.00 steals (1st in SBC) in 2007. He averaged 22.6 points (5th in nation and 1st in SBC) and 4.3 rebounds in 2005. He averaged 13.1 points and 3.5 rebounds in 2004. His single game scoring high was 39 points.